The Trench Reynolds Report

Without truth there is no justice

36-year-old Raphael Oyague, of Baldwin, New York, is accused of allegedly murdering a craigslist prostitute by beating her to death with a hammer. Oyague is said to have argued with his victim over money she believed she was owed before beating her then dumping her lifeless body in the weeds. Police were able to find …

Continue reading

24-year-old Daniel Williams is a security guard at a Long Island high school. He was arrested yesterday for allegedly recording a 16-year-old male student using the stall without the student’s knowledge. Williams then reportedly broadcast the recording over Snapchat. He is also said to have shared the video with another person while face to face …

Continue reading

Long Island Couple Accused Of Leaving 4 Kids Home Alone For 6 Days: Maria and Tulio Ayala of Central Islip, New York, on Long Island are accused of leaving their four kids, ages 15, 13, 8, and 4, at home for six days while they stayed at a hotel. No big deal right? The 15-year-old …

Continue reading

Man Convicted in Murder of Craigslist Prostitute: I originally posted about Chad Johnson (not Ochocinco) here. He was arrested last year for strangling, Jennifer Papain, a prostitute that he met on craigslist to death after she refused to give his money back. Johnson buried her in a shallow grave somewhere near the Long Island Expressway. …

Continue reading

Police discover corpses of three more victims of ‘Craigslist killer’: Police on Long Island have discovered four more bodies, three of which they have connected to the so-called Craigslist serial killer. If you recall back in December the bodies of Megan Waterman, Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, and Amber Lynn Costello. (pictured) All four of them …

Continue reading

Phone of slain craigslist hooker used in Times Square, MSG to taunt victim’s sister, sources say: Sources from New York law enforcement are saying that the sister of Melissa Barthelemy has received taunting phone calls from her sister’s cell phone. Barthelemy is one of the four victims killed by what police believe is a serial …

Continue reading

Serial killer theory returns to beach corpses case: Investigators in Long Island believe that the four female bodies found on their beaches were the work of a serial killer. As we know Megan Waterman was confirmed to be one of the victims. In addition to Megan Waterman the other three victims are Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, …

Continue reading

Maine Woman Among Gilgo Beach Bodies: This is a post I was hoping I would never have to make. The body of missing Maine mother Megan Waterman has been confirmed as being one of the bodies found in Long Island believed to be the work of serial killer that targets prostitutes from craigslist. Megan leaves …

Continue reading

Craigslist murder rampage: Missing prostitute feared to be one of four victims ‘Craigslist Killer’ dumped on a New York beach: Back when I was being interviewed by the media about Julissa Brisman’s murder my brother suggested I should write a book, fiction specifically. The idea I came up with after his suggestion was a serial …

Continue reading

Missing Craigslist escort’s boyfriend faces drug charge: I originally posted about Megan Waterman here. She’s the woman and mother from Maine who went missing while working as a craigslist escort on Long Island. Her pim…uh…traffick…I mean boyfriend, 20-year-old Akeem Cruz, was arrested in South Portland, Maine for being in possession of 13 rocks of crack. …

Continue reading